Locker Box vs Hiding a Spare Key: Outdoor Key Storage That’s Actually Secure

We’ve all been there—you or a family member gets locked out of the house, and the “solution” is digging under the doormat or lifting up the flowerpot to grab that spare key. But let’s be honest: those hiding spots are the first places burglars look.

In 2025, outdoor key storage has come a long way. Instead of hiding a spare under a rock, many homeowners are upgrading to secure locker boxes designed to keep keys accessible only to you (or trusted guests). But are key lock boxes really worth it, or is hiding a key still a reasonable option?

In this guide, we’ll compare locker boxes vs traditional hiding spots and explain why a purpose-built key storage system like the YARDLOCK Locker Box is the smart choice for security-minded homeowners.

The Problem With Hiding a Spare Key

Leaving a spare key outside is convenient—but also one of the biggest home security risks.

Why Hiding a Key is Risky

• Obvious spots: Burglars know to check under mats, rocks, planters, and ledges.
  

• Limited protection: A key left outdoors can be picked up by anyone, even delivery drivers or passersby.
  

• Weather exposure: Keys hidden in soil or under objects can rust or corrode.
  

• No access control: You can’t track who uses the key or when.
  

In short, hiding a spare key may save you one lockout—but it opens the door to much bigger risks.

What Is a Locker Box?

A locker box (also called a key lock box or outdoor key safe) is a secure container with a coded entry system. Instead of hiding a loose key, you place it inside the box. Only someone with the combination can open it.

Benefits of a Locker Box

• Controlled access: Share the code with family, cleaners, contractors, or Airbnb guests.
  

• Weatherproof: Designed to withstand rain, snow, and sun.
  

• Tamper-resistant: Built with reinforced steel and protective housings.
  

• Convenience: No more rushing across town to hand off a key.
  
  

The YARDLOCK Locker Box takes this a step further by being mechanical and keyless—no batteries, no Wi-Fi, and no electronic failures.

View Product

Locker Box vs Hiding a Key: Side-by-Side Comparison

When a Locker Box Makes Sense

Locker boxes are ideal if you:

• Run an Airbnb or rental property – Guests can self-check-in securely.
  

• Have cleaners, landscapers, or contractors who need access.
  

• Live with teenagers or elderly family members who may forget keys.
  

• Travel often and want a backup plan without leaving a key under the mat.
  

• Want to eliminate emergency lockouts without weakening security.
  

How to Install a Locker Box

One of the biggest advantages of locker boxes is that they’re easy to install.

✅ Step 1: Choose the Location

• Mount it on a solid surface near your entry, like a wall, post, or gate.
  

• Keep it discreet but accessible.
  

✅ Step 2: Drill & Mount

• Drill pilot holes and use the provided screws or anchors.
  

• Attach firmly so it can’t be pried off easily.
  

✅ Step 3: Set the Combination

• Choose a secure but memorable code.
  

• Avoid easy sequences like 1234 or your house number.
  

✅ Step 4: Test & Secure

• Place a spare key inside.
  

• Test multiple times to confirm smooth operation.
  

Security Best Practices for Locker Boxes

Even though locker boxes are far safer than hiding a key, follow these tips for maximum security:

• Change the code regularly (every few months or after giving access).
  

• Install at a discreet location (not directly at eye level on your front door).
  

• Check periodically for tampering or damage.
  

• Use a weatherproof cover if your area has extreme conditions.
  

Why YARDLOCK Locker Box Is a Smart Choice

The YARDLOCK Locker Box stands out for homeowners who want secure, keyless outdoor storage:

• No batteries or electronics – works in any weather.
  

• Mechanical system – easy for family, safe for access control.
  

• Tamper-resistant housing – designed to withstand prying.
  

• Versatile mounting – attach to fences, posts, or walls.
  

• Child & pet safety – no loose keys lying around.
  
  

It’s a practical upgrade that keeps your spare keys safe, while still giving you the convenience of controlled access.

Final Thoughts

Hiding a spare key under the doormat or planter might feel convenient, but it’s one of the easiest ways burglars gain entry. A locker box, especially a mechanical keyless option like YARDLOCK, gives you the security of controlled access without the risks.

Whether you need a backup for family members, safe access for Airbnb guests, or peace of mind when traveling, a locker box is a simple and smart upgrade over outdated hiding spots.

Stop hiding keys in plain sight—store them securely instead.